The Genius of And

Chalk Talk

Chalk Talk

I am prepping by reading the packet of articles for a class through Harvard’s Project Zero next week.

The mini session is called “Effective Professional Learning Communities:  Supporting Learning in  Staff Rooms and Classrooms”.   Daniel Wilson is the facilitator.  The first article is called Building a Professional Learning Community by Richard DuFour.

DuFour addresses a very real conundrum I see over and over in education “The Tyranny of the Or”:  the belief that we must make a choice between option A or option B.

  • Explicit Instruction vs Constructivism
  • Whole Language vs. Phonics
  • Workshop vs. Guided Reading
  • Multi-Tiered System of Support vs. Teach Well and Just love them

These false dichotomies, I believe, support unnecessary conflict in schools.  This is particularly evident when special educators and general educators have discussions about “how”  and “what”  to teach.

DuFour discusses how administrators often struggle with the “and/or” dichotomy when deciding how to lead.  Should they be the forceful leader or support site-based decisions?  Successful superintendents embrace “The Genius of And”;

“The strategy proven most effective, however, is one that is loose and tight, a strategy that establishes a clear priority and discernible parameters and then provides each school and department with the autonomy to chart its own course for achieving the objectives.”

If we all focused on the big idea (say, student learning) and truly know where our students are and what they need,  we will free ourselves up from this false dichotomy.  

even if it forces us to crack out the phonics book and do a little explicit instruction


One thought on “The Genius of And

  1. Pingback: If the Shoe Fits: Nurturing an Ecology | mpnENGAGED

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s